From BlackBerry Pearl 8130 to Palm Pre

As previously mentioned, I recently switched from a BlackBerry Pearl to a Palm Pre. I’ve been using the Pre for a little more than a month now and figured I put my thoughts about the switch up. I’ll follow roughly the same format I did when I switched to the BlackBerry. Unlike last time I did this, I’ll provide an outline here near the top with links down into the specific sections.

Things I liked about the BlackBerry that I’m missing now

Any time you switch to a new phone, especially if you change platforms, there’s things you miss about the old one.

Sleeper Magnet

I mentioned how nice this feature was in the post I made when I first got the BlackBerry and I never changed my mind about that. It was so nice to have the phone automatically switch to vibrate mode whenever it was in the holster. If it was in the holster, I wasn’t as likely to hear it ring but I was much more likely to feel it vibrate. It just kinda made sense. It was also nice walking into a movie theater or Church on Sunday and not having to worry about putting my phone on silent. If it was in the holster, I was good to go. Not a world changer by any stretch, but a nice convenience factor, for sure.

Voice Command

When I did my last review, I mentioned that the voice command on Windows Mobile was better than the BlackBerry. When I first got my Windows Mobile phone, it came with a pretty pathetic voice dialing application. It was the old school kind where you had to record voice tags for each contact. Even that was better than the voice command on the Pre… it doesn’t have one at all. We can hope that voice command is something they’ll add in a future OS update.

Battery Life

I kind of took a step backward on this one… but when I went to the BlackBerry I had taken two steps forward. So all told, I’m still a step ahead of my 6700. I can normally make it through a full day of normal use on the Pre’s battery. But on my BlackBerry, I could get almost two days of normal use. They sell two different extended life batteries. One that’s the same size as the stock battery [link to outdated product removed], so it doesn’t add any extra thickness to the phone while giving a slight power boost, and one that doubles the battery life [link to outdated product removed] but adds about 4mm of thickness to the phone and requires a new back (comes with the battery). I’m currently still using the stock battery, but we’ll see what happens as the phone ages.

Facebook Application

I mentioned when I got the BlackBerry how nice it was to have a Facebook Application and how much better it was than m.facebook.com. Well, now I’m back to a phone that doesn’t have one and I miss it. Sure, there’s touch.facebook.com, which the phone comes with a bookmark for (actually, it comes with a bookmark for x.facebook.com, but that redirects automatically to touch.facebook.com now days… same page, different URL), but it’s not the same thing as having an actual Facebook app. The Facebook app loads faster (it can use cached information). I also miss the ability to tag a photo as I upload it. The Pre does have some nice Facebook integration… for example, my phone contacts are automatically linked to my Facebook friends (if it gets the auto part wrong, I can manually correct it). This means that their Facebook photo can show up on my caller ID. It also means that if they’ve put their phone number on their Facebook profile it’s automatically in my phone book. The downside is, it grabs all my Facebook friends… including those who I just became “friends” with in order to gain something in a Facebook app or people I knew in High School but don’t talk to anymore. It still nice to have some idea what those old acquaintances are up to these days, but I don’t know that I need them in my phonebook. Photo uploading is also possible right from the photos application, but you can’t tag friends from the Pre.

Different Alerts for Different Events

I really miss this one. I could tell by the sound my phone made before if I had a text message, a work email, a personal email, an AKO (Army Knowledge Online… don’t have this account anymore) email, a Facebook message, or something else. On the Pre, not only is it not possible to set sounds for each of these events individually, but you can’t even change the default sound. My wife also has a Pre so if we’re both together, it can be difficult to know which one of us just got alerted… nevermind what the alert means. I’ve briefly tried the homebrew solutions to that problem, but didn’t really like them… though I do appreciate that they were at least an option. I’d imagine this is something coming in future OS updates.

CacheBerry

When we started Geocaching a while back, one of the first things I did was look for a way to go paperless. What I came across was CacheBerry. It was a nice little program that let me load GPX files into it filled with cache information which I could then use in the field to look at recent logs, hints, etc. I was also able to use it to keep track of what caches we found to make logging easier when we got home. Over the year or so I used it, a lot of new features got added. Unfortunately, there really isn’t anything similar for the Pre. So while it may just be an application that was available for the BlackBerry, it qualifies as something I miss about my old phone.

Things I like better about the Pre

Obviously I knew most, if not all, of the above things when I picked the Pre over an updated BlackBerry, so I must have had a reason…

Polished OS

There are those who would say that eye candy doesn’t matter. In fact, I used to be phone of them. I thought of all that animation (menus, windows transitions, task switching, etc) as nothing more than wasted CPU cycles. But as I use operating systems that have those things built into them I realize that they can be useful… as long as the animation is fast enough and stays out of the way of usability (nothing worse that not being able to do what you need because you’re waiting for an animation to complete). As I was watching videos of both the Palm Pre and the Android based HTC Hero one thing I noticed was that the Pre had a lot more polish to it. And, of course, both of those had more polish than my BlackBerry Pearl… and the Tour didn’t seem to be terribly much better in that department. The Pre and the Hero seemed to have similar, though not identical, capabilities. But the Pre had a physical keyboard and that’s still pretty important to me. I’ve used the virtual keyboard on an iPod Touch and it was possible to type on it, but I still prefer to pushing actual buttons. While the webOS software is still lacking a few features, I think it has a ton of potential. I’m definitely looking forward to the next few OS updates… especially if they get the GPU in the Pre working to it’s full potential!

Read status syncs

This was something that always annoyed me on my BlackBerry. I’d read a message on the phone and when I got back to the computer it’d normally be marked as read. But if I read it on the computer, the phone would never realize it. Even if I deleted it on the computer. The Pre, being that it uses Exchange Active Sync and IMAP to interface directly with the mailbox (whereas the BlackBerry goes through either a BES or BIS connection), is pretty always in sync. Sometimes it has to run the “sync process” first, but once it does the read and deleted status of each message is the same in both places.

Usable touch screen

The BlackBerry doesn’t have a touch screen at all, so any touch screen is going to be more usable than it had. Where I’m comparing “usable” here is actually two phones ago when I had the PPC-6700. That phone had a touch screen, but it wasn’t nearly as usable as the capacitive touch screen driven by webOS. One reason was that the 6700 used a resistive touch screen (the mainly being how much “touch” was required). Another reason is that the Pre is multitouch. I can handle being touched two different places at the same time and even react to it appropriately (such as pinch zooming). And lastly, webOS is built for being used with a finger whereas Windows Mobile was built for being used with a stylus. Switching between the screen and the keyboard on Windows Mobile was always a huge pain… even ignoring the fact that they keyboard was only in landscape mode so pulling it out meant rotating the phone.

Synergy Calendar

I tried for so long to get my work calendar, my personal Google calendar, and my Facebook calendar all onto the BlackBerry with only limited success. In the end, I was able to get the Google Calendar to sync using Google Sync. The problem with that was that I have a lot of calendars on my Google Calendar account and Google Sync could only lump them all onto one device calendar. It wanted to put all those events onto the device default calendar, which was my work calendar. So things would become a mess pretty quick with my personal items ending up on my work calendar. I really wanted to keep those two separate and I managed to find a setting on the BlackBerry that would cause Google Sync to put all its items on a different calendar (changed the device default calendar). I could only choose one remote calendar that all created events would go to, which wasn’t ideal, but it worked. I have a personal calendar and my wife and I have a shared calendar. Whenever I wanted to put something on the shared calendar and we were out and about I’d create it on the phone, it’d get synced to my personal calendar, then I’d have to remember to go online and move it to the shared calendar.

One the Pre, things are so much nicer. I added my Google Calendar account to the Calendar application (actually, it added it automatically when I added my gmail account to the mail app). I was then given the option for which calendars I wanted to view on my device. When I create an event, I can choose any calendar I have write access to (work, personal, shared w/my wife) and the event gets synced up to that calendar. If I want to display another calendar on my device (like the Detroit Lion’s schedule), I simple add it to my Google calendar and it’ll be available on my phone’s calendar. This multi-calendar display was possible with the combined calendar thing that Google Sync did, but on the Pre they can all be different colors.

Chat like text messaging

As I mentioned back when I did my other review, back when i was on Windows Mobile I started using threaded (chat-like) text messaging. I accomplished this by finding a third party program that replaced the default Windows Mobile text messaging program. That program was written by Palm when they started putting Windows Mobile on their handsets instead of PalmOS. That chat feature was a great selling point for their phones and they didn’t want to abandon it when they went to Windows Mobile (we’ll leave my other thoughts about Palm going to WM out of this). So I’m not at all surprised that the Pre has chat-like text messaging.

What is pleasantly surprising is that they didn’t stop there. They also added chat-like instant messaging. Well, instant messaging is pretty much the definition of chat, but what they did is integrate text messaging (SMS) and instant messaging (Google IM and AOL in the initial release). You can add your contact’s Google IM or AIM screen name to their contact information (it might be able to pull that down from Facebook, I’m not really sure) and then switch seamlessly between SMS and IM. OK, so there is a seam, but that’s just a small divider line so you known when the communication method changed.

Touchstone

The touchstone is one really slick piece of hardware. It enables you to charge the phone without plugging any cables into it. Simply set the phone on it and it starts charging. When it’s done, pick it up. If the phone rings while it’s setting on the touchstone and you pick it up, the call will be answered. If you’re in the middle of a call and you set the phone down on the touchstone, it will transfer it to speaker phone. Those are really nice software features of the phone; but, to be honest, they aren’t as useful as the aforementioned sleeper magnet in the BlackBerry.

If you get the Touchstone kit [link to outdated product removed], it comes with a new back for the phone and the touchstone itself. This new back is required for using the touchstone as it provides the phone part of the connection. That said, even without the touchstone requirement, the new back is nice because it’s a matte finish rather than a glossy one (which the standard cover has). The glossy finish is a real fingerprint magnet whereas the matte finish doesn’t really have that problem.

Summary

So here we are, more than 2,000 words later. I’d imagine I’ll be posting more about the Palm Pre and webOS in the future. Overall I like the phone. There are some shortcomings, but almost every one of them is software related. And the software is constantly improving. There’s actually a new update expected “soon.” When the Palm Pixie launch (this Sunday) it will have webOS 1.3.1 available for it. It’s expected that 1.3.1 will become available for the Pre soon after that.

3 thoughts on “From BlackBerry Pearl 8130 to Palm Pre”

  1. Hi Jake,

    Thanks for the article, great insights. I use a Pearl for my work Blackberry and use the Pre as my personal phone. I just wanted to let you know something I found to be most helpful regarding the facebook picture uploading. I haven’t figured how to tag people in it as I do it, but what made it easier is activating the mobile email upload. You go to your settings on facebook, and activate mobile, it gives you your own personal email. So, when you take a picture, send via email to that address, put the caption in the subject line, and it shows up on facebook as a caption. Tagging people, well that I haven’t figured out, but hopefully that will come with a future update. Overall, I love my phone, and the one thing I would like, is video record. Keeping my fingers crossed!
    Cheers!

  2. Blackberry is a business phone while palm is more a fun phone. Palm has many new features with in latest OS but BlackBerry is still the hot cake in market, both the PDA smart phones can be equipped with wide range of accessories, both BB and plam pre accessories are easily available.

    Have a look on following Youtube videos to have an insight of features of BlackBerry and Palm Pre.

    Palm Pre vs. iPhone 3G vs. Blackberry Storm
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pIzr2cdQywk

    Bold 9700 vs Palm Pre Part I – Hardware
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a3kUBcqdHoI

    Regards,
    WirelessPhoneGallery
    http://www.wirelessphonegallery.com/palm.aspx

Leave a Reply